JOSH & JOHN'S NATURALLY HOMEMADE ICE CREAMS
Whether it's Colorado Cookies and Cream, Chocolate Peanut Butler Chocolate Chip, Malted Mazel Toff or Yellow Cake-flavored, this sweet shop has been cranking out award-winning ice creams since 1985. This voter sums it up: "Their homemade fresh churned ice cream is simply the best. Hands down. No contest."